This is part of the Test Partnership interview questions series to help get the highest quality candidates.
Talk to one of our business psychologists about your needs to find out how candidate assessments can save you time and help you hire better people.
Critical thinking is one of the most sought-after soft skills employers look for in job candidates. The ability to analyze complex problems, weigh alternatives, and make logical decisions is invaluable for success across industries. During interviews, you can expect to face questions specifically designed to evaluate your critical thinking abilities.
Mastering thoughtful responses will prove you have the judgment and strategic mindset needed to thrive in the role. This article will arm you with examples and strategies for showcasing your critical thinking skills to land the job.
What Exactly is Critical Thinking?
Before diving into sample interview questions, let’s align on what critical thinking entails. At its core, critical thinking is the objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgment. It involves:
- Identifying gaps in information and seeking facts to fill them
- Challenging assumptions and examining them for validity
- Considering context, constraints, and alternate viewpoints
- Weighing the pros and cons of different options
- Anticipating potential consequences and impacts of decisions
- Applying logic and reasoning to interpret data, arguments, and conclusions
Critical thinkers exhibit curiosity open-mindedness and discernment. They actively apply strategies to decode problems and devise solutions.
Why Do Interviewers Ask Critical Thinking Questions?
Employers want to determine if you have the analysis judgment and decision-making abilities the role requires. Questions that test your critical thinking shed light on
-
How you break down complex issues – Your ability to identify root causes, make connections, and decompose problems methodically.
-
Your judgment under uncertainty – How you interpret ambiguous information and risks to derive sensible conclusions.
-
Your decision-making approach – How you generate, assess, and select options to arrive at sound solutions.
-
How you adapt when surprised – How you adjust your thinking when new variables or unexpected events arise.
-
How analytical you are – Your capacity to detach emotions and use evidence-based logic.
-
How creative you are – Your aptitude for discovering innovative solutions and possibilities.
Conveying these abilities is key to convincing interviewers you can navigate the role’s challenges.
8 Common Critical Thinking Interview Questions and How to Answer Them
Here are some of the most frequently asked critical thinking interview questions, along with strong sample responses:
1. Tell me about a time you had to solve a difficult problem. What was your thought process?
This question tests how you formulate a solution. A strong answer showcases your systematic approach.
Example response: “In my previous job, we suddenly started receiving customer complaints about inaccuracies in our billing statements. To pinpoint the cause, I first gathered information by reviewing the complaints, speaking to frontline staff, and auditing recent statement samples. I analyzed patterns in the errors, which revealed an outlier—they spiked after we had switched to a new billing system. Working with the operations team, we traced the issues back to a flaw in how the system calculated discounts. By methodically evaluating the evidence, we identified the root cause, after which I could develop targeted solutions to correct the system logic and prevent future mistakes. This example demonstrates my structured problem-solving process of collecting data, spotting patterns, uncovering the source, and addressing it.”
2. Tell me about a time you had to think on your feet. What was the situation and what did you do?
This tests how you process new information and adapt your thinking. The interviewer wants to see how you adjusted your approach to suit rapidly changing circumstances.
Example response: “When I was leading a team project, we were nearing the final stages of development when new requirements were suddenly added that changed the entire scope and objectives of the project. This surprise forced us to re-evaluate our strategy and workflow midstream. To adapt, I immediately met with my team to understand the new goals and brainstorm ideas to pivot our direction while minimizing rework of what was already complete. We ended up splitting tasks so that half the team continued finalizing existing components while the other half started developing the new pieces. This agile approach enabled us to simultaneously wrap up work in progress while actively addressing the new, urgent priorities. Despite having to think on our feet, we delivered an outcome that met both the original and emerging requirements.”
3. Tell me about a time you had to analyze facts quickly, define key issues, and respond immediately. What was the situation?
Here the interviewer wants to hear how you collect and process information under the pressure of time and urgency. Your response should demonstrate analytical thinking and decisive judgement.
Example response: “When our team suddenly lost access to our main database, everything ground to a halt. Our applications relied on that data, so the outage completely disrupted business operations. I immediately contacted our database administrator but quickly realized that this issue would take time to fix. My next step was to gather information from impacted teams about exactly which processes depended on this database. I had to rapidly analyze the collateral damage and downstream effects of the outage. Based on those facts, I defined two key issues: 1) The database contained transaction data that needed to be entered for continuity; 2) Analytics relying on real-time reporting were blocked. With these urgent issues in mind, I directed teams to shift to contingency processes using alternate tools while we awaited restoration. This allowed critical business areas to minimize disruption. My rapid analysis helped avert a larger crisis.”
4. Describe a situation where you had to solve a problem that didn’t have an obvious answer. How did you evaluate and weigh different solutions?
The interviewer wants insight into your judgment process when dealing with ambiguous or complex problems. Your answer should outline analytical methods for assessing alternatives.
Example response: “As a project manager, I was once faced with the challenge of devising a testing strategy for a new product that had a tremendous number of possible usage scenarios and permutations. With so many variables, it wasn’t feasible to test them all, and we had to prioritize strategically. I started by creating a matrix to map all the potential factors we could vary in testing against the probability and impact of failures related to those factors. This allowed me to identify and quantify risks associated with missing certain test cases. Using this risk framework, I could objectively compare the merits of different testing plans based on how thoroughly they addressed high risk areas. Balancing coverage with practical limitations, I selected an optimized approach targeting tests with the greatest risk mitigation. Evaluating options systematically was key to designing a test strategy that maximized results within constraints.”
5. Describe a time when you needed to analyze a situation and make a quick decision. What factors did you consider?
This question evaluates your ability to make rapid decisions under pressure by isolating relevant factors. Convey your deduction process and judgment skills.
Example response: “When a storm caused a power outage across our facilities, I had to act fast to redirect resources and staff to minimize disruptions. With limited generator power, I first isolated the most critical infrastructure that had to remain online, considering factors like active data centers, security systems, and refrigeration units. I assessed which non-essential systems could go offline until power was restored. Considering staff safety was also essential, so I determined which areas provided necessary lighting versus which could operate safely with torches and flashlights if needed. With these key factors analyzed, I could make swift decisions on equipment shutdown sequencing and staff assignments to keep critical areas functioning during the outage. My snap judgment prevented major business disruptions.”
6. Walk me through your process for making a difficult decision that affected multiple stakeholders. How did you include different perspectives?
Here the interviewer wants to understand your inclusive decision-making process. Demonstrate how you incorporate different viewpoints.
Example response: “When determining how to allocate annual budget funds across different department initiatives, I recognized that I needed input from our various leaders to understand priorities from their perspectives. I scheduled one-on-one consultations with each head to discuss plans and gain insight into how potential budget allocations would impact their groups’ objectives. Synthesizing these diverse views, I developed a ranking methodology based on factors like strategic alignment, revenue impact, and cost. In cases where priorities conflicted, I facilitated open discussions where heads could express their needs and arrive at mutually agreeable solutions. My inclusive approach enabled me to make balanced decisions on fund allocation that optimized outcomes across the company.”
7. Describe a time you had to solve a problem without having all the necessary information. What did you do?
This question probes your analytical abilities when dealing with incomplete data. Showcase how you derive logical conclusions despite uncertainties.
Example response: “As a consultant, clients often present problems without providing the full context needed to develop a detailed solution. In these situations, I take a methodical approach to determine what information I absolutely need versus what is supplementary. I ask probing questions of stakeholders to extract foundational details to frame the issue. Where I lack specific data points, I make reasonable assumptions based on available evidence and precedence. I’m always transparent about areas where I’ve had to assume or approximate so clients understand any risks associated with those gaps. This analytical approach of extracting the vital facts allows me to still provide valuable guidance. I derive logical solutions while noting dependencies on forthcoming data, setting proper client expectations.”
8. How do you stay motivated when faced with problems that seem to have no obvious solution?
Finally, the interviewer wants to understand your perseverance and positive mindset when tackling daunting challenges
5 Effective Interview Questions to Measure Critical Thinking
Lead consultant at Test Partnership, Ben Schwencke, explains why Critical Thinking is worth measuring.
Effective critical thinking is an essential cognitive ability in todays fast-paced and complex business environment. It’s important for employers to hire people who can look at data, find patterns, and make good decisions based on facts and logic. As a result, measuring critical thinking has become an important part of the hiring process.
Even though cognitive ability tests are useful, interviews are still an important part of the hiring process because they show how well a candidate can think critically.
To measure critical thinking effectively during interviews, employers need to ask the right questions. This article will explore five effective interview questions that can help measure critical thinking skills in candidates. Each question is designed to assess a different aspect of critical thinking, such as problem-solving, decision-making, and creativity. This article will give you five good interview questions to test your critical thinking skills, along with tips on how to give a strong or weak answer.
How do you approach problems that have no clear solution or path forward? A
Would showcase the candidates ability to use critical thinking to approach complex problems. The candidate should be able to show that they can break a problem down into smaller parts, come up with possible solutions, and decide what to do by weighing different factors. A good answer should also show that the candidate can learn from new information and change their approach as needed. B.
Might lack structure or clarity. The candidate may not be able to clearly explain how they plan to solve problems, or they may give vague or general examples that don’t show how they can think critically. A weak answer might also lack specifics or proof to back up the candidate’s claims, which could mean they don’t have a good history of using critical thinking to solve hard problems. Lastly, a bad answer could mean that the candidate can’t change their mind or adapt to new information, which could mean that they have trouble working well in a dynamic or changing environment.
- 1. Why not break the problem into smaller pieces that you can handle better?
- 2. What factors do you consider when evaluating potential solutions?
- 3. When making a choice, how do you rank and weigh the different things that matter?
How do you prioritize competing demands or conflicting goals when making decisions? A
Would demonstrate the candidates ability to use critical thinking to evaluate complex situations with conflicting demands or goals. The candidate should be able to explain how they make decisions, including what factors they look at and how they decide how important each one is. A good answer should also show that the candidate can make decisions based on facts and after carefully and strategically thinking about the situation. B.
Might lack structure or clarity. The candidate may not be able to clearly explain how they make decisions, or they may give vague or general examples that don’t show how they can think critically. A weak answer might also lack specifics or proof to back up the candidate’s claims, which could mean they don’t have a good track record of using critical thinking to figure out what’s going on in tough situations. Lastly, a bad answer could mean that the candidate can’t make decisions based on data or put different needs or goals in the right order, which could mean that they won’t be able to work well in a fast-paced or high-pressure environment.
- 1. What do you think about when you have to choose between different needs or goals?
- 2. How do you weigh the importance of each factor?
- 3. Could you tell me about a time when you had to choose between different needs or wants? How did you make your choice?
Can you describe a time when you had to weigh the pros and cons of different options in order to make a choice?
Would showcase the candidates ability to use critical thinking to evaluate complex situations and make data-driven decisions. The applicant should be able to explain their clear way of making decisions, including the things they think about and how they weigh the pros and cons of each choice. A good answer should also show that the candidate can think about what happened and whether they think they made the right choice. It should also show what they would do differently in the future. B.
Might lack structure or clarity. The candidate may not be able to clearly explain how they make decisions, or they may give vague or general examples that don’t show how they can think critically. A weak answer might also lack specifics or proof to back up the candidate’s claims, which could mean they don’t have a good track record of using critical thinking to figure out what’s going on in tough situations. Lastly, a bad answer could mean that the candidate can’t think about what happened or how they made decisions. This could mean that they find it hard to learn from their mistakes and get better at making decisions over time.
- 1. What factors did you consider when evaluating each option?
- 2. How did you figure out what the pros and cons of each choice might be?
- 3. Could you talk about how the decision turned out and whether you think it was the right one?
How do you handle situations where there is no clear precedent or established process to follow? A
Would demonstrate the candidates ability to think critically and adapt to new and challenging situations. The candidate should be able to explain how they solve problems, including how they gather information, weigh different options, and make decisions based on data. A good answer should also show that the candidate can think creatively and outside the box, since critical thinking often means coming up with new ways to solve difficult problems. B.
Might lack structure or clarity. The candidate may not be able to clearly explain how they plan to solve problems, or they may give vague or general examples that don’t show how they can think critically. A weak answer might also lack specifics or proof to back up the candidate’s claims, which could mean they don’t have a good track record of handling new and difficult situations. Lastly, a bad answer could mean that the candidate can’t think outside the box or creatively, which could mean that they have trouble coming up with new ways to solve tough problems.
- 1. How do you go about getting facts and figuring out what’s going on?
- 2. What factors do you look at when deciding what the best thing to do is?
- 3. Give an example of a time when you had to make a choice without a clear precedent or set procedure. How did you handle the situation?
How do you ensure that your decision-making process is objective and data-driven? A
Would demonstrate the candidates ability to use critical thinking to make objective and data-driven decisions. The candidate should be able to explain how they make decisions, including what information they use and how they weigh different pieces of information. One more thing that a good answer should show is that the candidate can make decisions based on data and analysis, not just gut feelings or personal preferences. B.
Might lack structure or clarity. The candidate may not be able to clearly explain how they make decisions, or they may give vague or general examples that don’t show how they can think critically. A weak answer might also lack specifics or proof to back up the candidate’s claims, which could mean they don’t have a good history of using data and analysis to help them make decisions. Lastly, a bad answer could mean that the candidate can’t balance different pieces of information or make objective choices, which could mean that they have trouble making good decisions in a fast-paced or high-pressure setting.
- 1. What sources of information do you use when making decisions?.
- 2. How do you weigh conflicting information or data points?
- 3. Could you give an example of a time when you used data and analysis to make a choice?
TOP 7 CRITICAL-THINKING SKILLS Interview Questions and ANSWERS!
FAQ
What does critical thinking mean in interview?
What are the five points of critical thinking?
What are the 4 basics of critical thinking?
Why is critical thinking important in a job interview?
Critical thinking abilities are valuable in almost all roles and industries. As a result, interviewers often ask questions to assess your skills at identifying problems and developing optimal solutions using logic. You can impress potential employers by using examples that showcase the analytic thought process behind your decision making.
How do interviewers test critical thinking?
Interviewers may try to test this skill by asking you critical thinking questions. To feel more confident in the interview and improve your chances of getting the job, it’s best to prepare for these questions beforehand. In this article, we provide 10 critical thinking interview questions and sample answers you can use to help you prepare.
What questions do you ask about critical thinking skills?
Questions about your critical thinking skills are often behavioral interview questions. These are a strategic type of interview questions that require you to provide an answer that includes an example situation that you experienced in your career and how you acted in that situation.
Are You Ready for a critical thinking interview?
To ensure you’re ready for your interview, here are 10 common critical thinking questions interviewers may ask to test your skills, along with sample answers to help you prepare your own: 1. Describe one of the most difficult decisions you have had to make at work.
