Achievment Goal Theory is a theory that argues a person’s degree of motivation to achieve a goal is influenced by their goal orientation.
Goal orientation refers to the rationale underpinning our goals. We can either approach a goal in two broad ways:
Generally, scholars argue that mastery goal setting leads to greater intrinsic motivation, resilience, and determination to complete the goal. Performance goals, on the other hand, tend to lead to waning motivation over time due to their reliance on extrinsic rewards.
The theory’s value is in helping us to reflect upon how we are formulating and conceptualizing goals, with the understanding that the ways goals are framed will affect how motivated we are to strive for them.
Achievement goal theory is a highly useful framework for business managers seeking to motivate employees and boost performance. This article explains what achievement goal theory is its key principles, and how it applies in real-world business contexts.
What is Achievement Goal Theory?
Originally formulated in the field of education achievement goal theory proposes that the types of goals people set influence their motivation effort, resilience, and achievement.
It distinguishes between mastery goals and performance goals:
-
Mastery goals focus on developing competence, gaining skills and knowledge The aim is to achieve mastery over a task
-
Performance goals focus on demonstrating competence relative to others. The aim is to gain recognition, rewards, status.
Additionally, there are approach and avoidance variants of both goal types:
-
Approach goals are focused on achieving success.
-
Avoidance goals are focused on avoiding failure.
So the four key goal orientations are:
- Mastery-approach
- Mastery-avoidance
- Performance-approach
- Performance-avoidance
The theory outlines how each orientation impacts motivation, persistence, learning, and overall performance.
Goal Orientations in Business
While initially studied in education contexts, achievement goal theory is highly relevant for business management.
Leaders can promote mastery or performance goal climates through their policies, messaging and incentives. This shapes employees’ personal goal orientations.
Below are examples of how the four goal orientations manifest in workplace settings:
Mastery-Approach Goals
Employees with mastery-approach goal orientation are driven by intrinsic motivation to gain expertise. For example:
- A software developer learning a complex new coding language to become proficient in it
- An accountant pursuing CPA certification to master auditing skills
- A manager taking leadership courses to improve their skills
Mastery-Avoidance Goals
Employees with mastery-avoidance goals shy away from challenges fearing failure to learn. For example:
- An analyst declining to work on a project using new analytics tools they haven’t used before
- A marketing executive avoiding leading a brand repositioning project they feel unprepared for
Performance-Approach Goals
Employees with performance-approach orientation seek extrinsic rewards like promotions, bonuses, accolades. For example:
- A salesperson competing fiercely to be the top performer and win sales contests
- A finance professional working long hours to get promoted faster
Performance-Avoidance Goals
Employees with performance-avoidance goals focus on avoiding negative judgment by others. For example:
- A team member staying silent in meetings to avoid looking unprepared if they speak up
- An employee declining to share innovative ideas fearing criticism from colleagues
Key Principles of Achievement Goal Theory
Here are some key insights from achievement goal theory that managers should know:
-
Mastery goals lead to deeper engagement, willingness to take on challenges and intrinsic motivation – key traits for high performance.
-
Performance goals, while driving short-term results, often lead employees to take shortcuts or lose motivation when rewards are limited.
-
An approach orientation encourages employees to seek positive outcomes. This motivates achieving success.
-
An avoidance orientation focuses excessively on preventing failure. This can limit risk-taking and innovation.
-
Goal climate set by management heavily influences employees’ personal goal orientations.
-
Environments allowing failure enable a mastery climate. Punitive environments encourage performance-avoidance.
-
Goals emphasizing collaboration and teamwork minimizes performance orientation.
-
Clear attainable goals with autonomy boosts mastery orientation. Imposed ambiguous goals spur avoidance.
Applying Achievement Goal Theory
Here are some practical tips for managers to create a mastery-oriented climate:
-
Set challenging but realistic team and individual goals focused on skill/knowledge development.
-
Recognize effort and progress rather than just achievement. Praise hard work.
-
Allow and normalize failure. Treat setbacks as learning opportunities, not punishments.
-
Encourage collaborative learning and development. De-emphasize competition between employees.
-
Tie rewards and promotions more strongly to competence gains than short-term performance metrics.
-
Give employees autonomy in setting their learning goals and path to achieving them.
-
Be a role model by pursuing mastery goals in your own development.
Additionally, here are some examples of applying achievement goal theory across key HR functions:
Recruitment
Hire employees intrinsically motivated by the work itself, not just compensation. Assess mastery orientation in interviews.
Learning & Development
Design training to build competence through stretch assignments, not lectures. Enable employees to track mastery progression.
Performance Management
Set goals focused on skill/knowledge development. Assess progress based on competence gained rather than targets met.
Compensation & Rewards
Link pay and bonuses more strongly to competence development through new skills rather than short-term output.
Leadership Development
Coach leaders to set team goals focused on mastery. Train them to create psychologically safe, failure-tolerant cultures.
Organizational Culture
Continually emphasize importance of learning and collaboration. Celebrate growth mindsets and knowledge sharing.
Benefits of Mastery Goal Orientation
Research shows that mastery goal orientation delivers a range of benefits:
-
Greater persistence at challenging tasks
-
More use of learning strategies and adapting approaches to improve
-
Increased help seeking from others to enhance learning
-
Higher engagement resulting in greater effort
-
Intrinsic motivation leading to sustained commitment
-
Knowledge sharing – teaching skills to others reinforces own learning
-
Career self-management by seeking assignments aligned to development needs
-
Innovation through experimentation and learning from failures
These benefits are amplified when the whole team or organization adopts a shared mastery climate.
Achievement goal theory offers a powerful framework for business leaders seeking to maximize employee performance. It provides actionable insights on how to design goals, incentives, training programs and organizational culture to bring out the best in people.
A mastery climate fulfills intrinsic needs for competence and growth. This drives sustainable high performance, unlike short-term extrinsic rewards. Managers can reap substantial gains by promoting mastery orientation across their teams and companies.
Achievement Goal Theory Overview
Two key concepts in achievement goal theory are goal orientation and goal structure.
Early theorists of Achievement Goal Theory posited that goals tend to be based on achievement or mastery, as outlined above.
However, based on the research of A. J. Elliot (Elliot & McGregor, 2001), the 2×2 model of goal setting was developed. This model splits mastery and performance goals into two parts based on approach (seeking reward or growth) and avoidance (avoiding punishment or failure):
- Mastery-approach: Wanting to complete a task for the purpose of self-improvement and learning as much as possible.
- Mastery-avoidance: Wanting to avoid a task because they feel they won’t learn as much as they need to in order to complete the task.
- Performance-approach: The desire to complete a task in order to outperform a peer group, achieve the appearance of superiority, and receive an extrinsic reward.
- Performance-avoidance: The desire to avoid the task to evade embarrassment, shame, self-doubt, or public failure (Wolters, 2004).
Dweck (1999), famous for her work on mindsets, argues that mastery-avoidance and performance-avoidance correspond with a fixed mindset. This is a mindset where people avoid a task because they don’t believe they have the capacity for improvement or success.
By contrast, mastery-approach and performance-approach correlate with a growth mindset, where a person’s focus is primarily on what they’re capable of, if they put in the effort.
Goal structure (also known as goal climate) refers to the institutional environment in which goals are assigned.
An institution (such as a workplace or school) sets in place a culture that can influence a person’s goal orientation.
- Mastery goal structure: If the institution sends signals that it values mastery (e.g. doing a task for the sake of being good at the task), it is considered to have a mastery goal structure. This sort of a goal climate will encourage people to set mastery goals.
- Performance goal structure: If the institution sends signals that it most highly values rewards and outcomes (e.g. a school focused on standardized test scores or workplace renumeration based on commissions), it is considered to have a performance goal structure. This sort of a goal climate will encourage people to set performance goals.
Furthermore, an institution that punishes failure may encourage an avoidance mindset. By contrast, an institution that embraces failure as a natural part of growth may encourage an approach mindset (with recognition that failure isn’t a big deal and doesn’t represent loss of face).
Researching of Achievement Goal Theory – Essay Example
How did achievement goal theory evolve?
Discussion of origins and evolution of the theory. Suggestions for future directions focusing on methods, complexity, and diversity. Quickly after its introduction in the early 1980′s, achievement goal theory blossomed into one of the most popular frameworks in motivation research. Over three plus decades, the theory evolved in a number of ways.
Why are achievement goals important?
They function as an impetus to move the achievement goal theory forward, helping it reach greater conceptual and methodological precision as well as more diverse spheres of achievement exertions. Achievement goal researchers have welcomed novel insights from outside and actively incorporated them into the theory and research.
What are the principles of Achievement Goal Theory?
The principles of achievement goal theory involve understanding the various motivations associated with individual decision-making and evaluation. Here are the four main principles of achievement goal theory:
Is Achievement Goal Theory a viable account of human motivation?
Despite its long-lasting contributions to the field of educational psychology, we believe achievement goal theory has now reached its critical juncture. The courses of development in the next few years may determine the theory’s longevity as a viable account of human motivation, especially for children and adolescents in achievement settings.
