I am frequently questioned about the “union vs. non-union” controversy. Here are my opinions because I’m sick of the strife it causes when people disagree over which is superior.
Electricians in both unions and non-unions can be excellent and terrible. Whether a person is going to make a good electrician or not depends on them. There are many excellent electricians on both sides of the political spectrum, and if you ask a city inspector, they’ll tell you that both sides occasionally produce subpar work.
Although the electrical union is a well-lit, safe route, it feels cramped, like being inside MACHINE by Pink Floyd. It’s a fantastic opportunity if you enjoy a lot of structure, order, and similarity. Non-union employment is also a great option if you’d prefer a slightly more lenient, flexible, merit-based system. In contrast to non-union workers, unions guarantee wages, healthcare, and benefits. Although many non-union businesses also offer these benefits, it just depends on the employer
I believe it is more crucial to consider the output of the various trade schools. Most trade schools are garbage. They give you little training for a lot of money, and when you start working, people will treat you like you still don’t know what you’re doing. This trade is 100% tools on. The most crucial lesson to impart to learners is that, and classrooms should support it. Most trade schools only offer classroom instruction and lack any equipment or fieldwork. These children spend a year or two learning and a lot of their parents’ money, but when they are on a job site, they are unable to operate a drill. They are not worth more than they were prior to attending school. THIS IS A PROBLEM.
Union or not, there are only two possible routes up the same hill. Go union if you prefer paved paths; go non-union if you prefer scenic routes. Either way, you must work hard and develop high-caliber craftsmanship if you want to reach the top of the hill. Being a good electrician is a choice. Daily.
Union vs Non-Union Electricians. What’s the difference?
Training and education
Apprenticeship programs are required for all electricians, union and non-union, in order to develop the skills and capabilities required to perform electrical roles. To enable professionals to obtain their electrical journeyman license, these apprenticeships typically combine classroom instruction with on-the-job training. As previously mentioned, the Joint Apprenticeship & Training Committee (JATC) collaborates with the IBEW and NECA to offer union apprenticeships. These apprenticeships are frequently cited as excellent, demanding development opportunities, and the union pays professionals standard wages for them.
It’s important to remember, however, that applying to union apprenticeship programs can be difficult because of the strict hiring criteria that unions have. On the other hand, non-union electricians can finish their apprenticeships through organizations like the ABC or IEC. For professionals with little education and experience, many non-union shops may cover the costs of such training programs. However, in order to be eligible for these opportunities, you may need to first pursue formal technical training by earning a certificate or enrolling in a trade school.
Benefits
As a perk of their employment, union and non-union electricians may receive different benefits. Guaranteed pensions, which enable union electricians to retire and receive regular monthly installments after completing a certain amount of time in their role, are among the many benefits that union membership typically entails. Given that many employers have systematically eliminated pensions across the U.S., this benefit is extremely competitive. S. workforce in recent years. Union electricians typically anticipate receiving medical and dental benefits for themselves and their families in addition to a pension.
Benefits plans may be provided to non-union electricians through the businesses that hire them, and these benefits may vary from one employer to another. In some non-union workplaces, employees’ contributions to 401(k) or Individual Retirement Account (IRA) plans from their paychecks are matched up to 10%. Although this gives non-union electricians more control over their retirement funds, it might not be as stable as pensions. Even so, non-union electricians frequently receive some kind of medical coverage, especially if they work for a business with at least 50 staff members.
Please note that Indeed is not affiliated with any of the businesses mentioned in this article.
What is a non-union electrician?
A non-union electrician is a construction expert who works for a non-union company, works independently, or owns a non-union electrical company. Non-union electricians typically receive their training from outside formal vocational institutions, such as trade schools, or through apprenticeships at particular contracting firms. Furthermore, they could enroll in apprenticeship programs run by Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc. The leading non-union trade association organizations in the United States are (ABC) or Independent Electrical Contractors (IEC). Apprenticeship programs are sponsored by both the ABC and the IEC for non-union electrical contracting businesses and shops with which they collaborate.
Non-union electricians may receive their training from numerous different trade associations and educational institutions, so their credentials and abilities can vary greatly. However, non-union electricians often perform the same tasks as union electricians, and sometimes their daily responsibilities are very similar. However, because of this, non-union electricians might have access to opportunities that go beyond those provided to their professionals by unions. This is particularly true in some geographic areas, like the southern United States, where the IBEW does not host local chapters. S. where few unions have contracts.
A trade school is where both union and non-union electricians start their educational journey. The course’s material emphasizes electrical codes, blueprint reading, wiring, workplace safety, and the use of electrical materials on construction sites. A. If accepted, a union electrician applies to join as a student and is given a three-year apprenticeship set up by the union. Additional classes are required, before becoming certified. A non-union electrician is frequently assigned to an apprenticeship by their educational institution, and after three years of experience under the supervision of a Master Electrician, they are eligible to take the licensing exam. To become a Master Electrician, both union and non-union electricians must first work as Journeyman Electricians and pass a licensing test. Licenses must be renewed every two years, and electricians must continue their education to keep their licenses.
A qualified electrician can create and install electrical systems. An electrician’s job is frequently dangerous because they must work in cramped areas, in bad weather, and with materials that can shock them. As an electrician, you have the option of working independently or as a union member. A union membership has numerous advantages, such as paid training, employment opportunities, paid benefits, and retirement benefits. Apprenticeship in the union is required, and the training is frequently in-depth. In contrast, a non-union position allows an individual to work independently as an electrician after completing their education requirements and earning their Journeyman license.
The average salary for electricians in 2017 was $51,110, or $26. 01 per hour, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Master electricians can anticipate higher pay, particularly if they run their own business or manage employees. Average hourly wages for union electricians are $15 more, and they also receive insurance and retirement benefits.
Both regular and union electricians perform the same tasks in their jobs. An electrician’s responsibilities include designing wiring plans for homes and businesses, installing appliances and fixtures, wiring, and maintaining breaker boxes. Some electricians work in commercial settings, where they must plan extensive electrical systems using computer software. A master electrician has the authority to direct others and instruct apprentices. Union members are often referred to companies for specific jobs. Independent electrical contractors run their own businesses or work for small enterprises. Generating work independently is required for non-union electricians.
The types of jobs an electrician performs depend on their level of experience. Becoming a Master Electrician requires substantial experience. For referrals and a steady clientele, independent electricians must make payments.
When things take a turn for the worse, having a union steward is especially crucial. There is someone to assist you in fighting the business on your behalf if it fails to pay you what is due or in a timely manner, dismisses you without cause, or if something just seems off. The union works to ensure that contracts cover both parties and that the total compensation that these men and women receive is reasonable. He claimed that he is unaware of any union members who are paid more than what is stipulated in the union contracts. We also receive raises every year as a result of the contracts in place. And it’s usually a fairly good bump. The local where we currently work will give us a $1 in June of this year. They will be increasing the hourly wage by 16 and adding $1 to the NEAP contribution. 00/ hour as well.
Remember that this blog featured FOUR women in FOUR distinct circumstances. What is best for you to do is up to you and your family to decide. There is absolutely no reason to judge them for their choices because what works for one family won’t work for another. No one has ever changed their mind after being called names or treated cruelly. Choose to be kind because you have no idea what other people are going through. Ultimately, whether you choose to be in a union or not, these linemen are risking everything.
The Pension AND Annuity Plan is on an entirely different level (yes, you read that correctly; the Union has set up TWO retirement accounts for you). Each of the halls you work in will have a different contribution percentage. Most non-union businesses limit their employees’ contributions to a 401(K), which must be matched 1:1 and has a 3-6% cap. Although it varies from IBEW local to local, generally 10–25% of your gross pay is invested for you in an annuity account without you having to put any of your own money into it. No match required.
Safety is such a huge part of the union. There is a book called the RED Book, which is an 89-page manual on how to handle various situations, in the hall where we are currently working. This is to help protect all parties involved. An employee does not have to feel intimidated into performing a task that could cause them harm or death while at work if they feel unsafe doing it. They have the right to speak up to the company without fear of retaliation.
My husband started Line Work in 2004. Over the years he has worked for several different contractors. He has done Transmission, Distribution and Underground. He literally began at the bottom when he first began. Starting out, it was common to switch jobs frequently in search of better pay and more work. Due to his job, he has commuted both near and far from home, spending months apart from each other. He has worked in both extreme heat and bitter cold (he actually prefers the heat, LOL). For the past five and a half years, he has worked for the same contractor. He has taken a ton of classes for various subjects in addition to on-the-job training. Despite what most people seem to believe, they take the safety of their employees very seriously. They have treated my husband and our family with such kindness. They ensure that you can attend your children’s school award ceremonies and Father’s Day breakfast despite the fact that your job may unexpectedly pull you away from your regular life. Our family now has lifelong friends who fully comprehend what it’s like to lead this lifestyle thanks to this company. Tragically, whether unionized or not, working in this field brings with it tragedies. When that occurs, everyone in my husband’s workplace rallies to offer their unwavering support. Now that we are in the present, he has worked his way up from being a grunt to a foreman. He has sacrificed a great deal for his position. Within his company, the pay and per diem are very competitive. They provide a 401K, health insurance, life insurance, and paid time off. The health insurance is fairly good for a family and is actually less expensive on a monthly basis than through my job with the government. They have never refused to pay for something that is necessary, so far. The prescription coverage is pretty great as well. Every six months, they are evaluated in addition to receiving a respectable pay raise. They always have what they need to finish the job, and the equipment is kept up to date. The ultimate objective for anyone working in this field, union or not, is to return home safely and to keep your brother from harm. Only those who have experienced this job’s way of life can truly understand it.
Joining a Non-Union Shop as an Electrician’s Apprentice
A non-union shop is more like the typical job application process that most people are used to: obtain some formal training through a trade school, respond to an advertisement for an apprenticeship or trainee position with a particular contracting company, submit an application, attend an interview, and attempt to get the job.
As an alternative, you can enroll in an apprenticeship program through Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc. (ABC) or Independent Electrical Contractors (IEC), two significant non-union trade associations that help sponsor and facilitate apprenticeship programs through the non-union electrical contracting firms that are members of them.
To obtain your journeyman license, you would need to complete the required number of hours of on-the-job training and classroom instruction through ABC or IEC.
FAQ
What is the difference between union and non-union electricians?
Union electricians typically anticipate receiving medical and dental benefits for themselves and their families in addition to a pension. Benefits plans may be provided to non-union electricians through the businesses that hire them, and these benefits may vary from one employer to another.
What are the four classifications of electricians?
When pursuing a career as an electrician, there are four specialty areas to select from. These jobs include residential wiremen, installer technicians, inside wiremen, and outside linemen.
What are the 3 main types of electricians?
The three different kinds of electricians and what they do Electrical contractors frequently have different areas of expertise, such as commercial electrician, residential electrician, and industrial electrician.
What are the benefits of being a union electrician?
Unions are responsible for 40-hour work weeks, weekends, sick pay, vacation pay, paid family leave, medical insurance, and retirement benefits through the leverage of collective bargaining.
